arrow-circle arrow-long-stroke arrow-stroke arrow-thick arrow-thin arrow-triangle icon 2 baseballCreated with Sketch. basketball calendar category check-circle check-square check comment facebook-circle facebook-icon facebook-rounded facebook-square facebook-stroke football instagram-circle instagram-icon instagram-square long-arrow-right rss-circle rss-rounded rss-square rss-stroke rss twitter-circle twitter-icon twitter-rounded twitter-square twitter-stroke user-group user

What’s Ailing the Auburn Offense?

By on January 3rd, 2018 in Football 7 Comments »

The good news: Auburn beat its two biggest rivals for the first time since 2013 and made it to SEC Championship game. The bad news: Auburn was destroyed in the SEC Championship, the two rivals are playing for the National Championship, and Auburn lost to UCF, the first Group of Five loss since 1991. The loss was embarrassing and to some makes Auburn look like the laughing stock of college football. Related items: Gus Malzahn received a massive contract and has virtually nothing to show for it. How does this happen?

Auburn’s last play of the season was a microcosm of the entire season. Clinging to life and needing a touchdown to force overtime, Auburn found rhythm and tempo, driving the field because Jarrett Stidham finally found an intermediate passing game in the form of Will Hastings. This, after turning in the LSU game V2.0 for much of the second half in Atlanta. Then, center Casey Dunn goes down, and coach Herb Hand has to shuffle the line. With a new left tackle in the game and Austin Golson at center, UCF did what any team would do: jailbreak blitz the new player. The line couldn’t hold, Stidham panicked and threw the game-sealing pick. It was the worst possible play call available. Still, that’s just one play. The whole bowl game, Auburn’s offense was lost. Much like the last two games against Clemson. Much like the last bowl game against Oklahoma. As in any game where Malzahn and Co. had time to prepare. 

Jarrett Stidham passed for 3,000 yards this season, becoming just the second player in Auburn history behind Dameyune Craig to do so. It was 3,000 meaningless yards as is his solid 151 rating and 70.7 adjusted QBR. Stidham couldn’t win games when needed. He had a total of three touchdowns and four turnovers in Auburn’s four losses. There were certainly moments when Stidham looked the part of the quarterback the Auburn fan base expected. But for the much of the season, he looked completely lost. 

Obviously it wasn’t all on him. The offensive line must share the blame. This unit looked poised to be the top unit in the SEC in the preseason, and that thought wasn’t just from my orange tinted glasses. Most talking heads agreed that an all upper-classman line that had two legitimate NFL players (Braden Smith and Austin Golson) seemed like a lock to be one of the country’s top units. After two weeks, Auburn was the worst team in America in sacks allowed. Herb Hand changed the lineup and things got better… for a while. Still, in Auburn’s last two games of the season, this unit was completely dominated. 

Auburn landed arguably the best wide-receiver recruiting class in the country in 2015, bolstering an already stellar class from the year before. Malzahn added Noah Igbinoghene and Sal Cannella. Again, this unit pulled down over 3,000 yards and 17 touchdowns but struggled mightily to get open against even mediocre coverage units. Was play better than previous years? Absolutely. Was it SEC level? Far from it. The only SEC-type catch was the Darius Slayton catch against UGA. How can Auburn recruit such players but fail to get these athletes to look like SEC caliber players? On a related note, Auburn’s most consistent receiver wasn’t one of the top recruited guys. Will Hastings ended the year fourth in catches, third in yards and completely ignored in the meat of the season. 

In addition, Malzahn refused to give other running backs a legitimate chance to provide relief for an oft-injured Kerryon Johnson. Kam Martin ended the year averaging 6.1 yards per carry while rushing for 450 yards on 70 attempts. Yet, there was never any attempt to utilize him to his talent level, even against inferior competition. Even when Martin got Auburn into the red zone, his reward was watching Johnson and Pettway score. Of his three touchdowns, one was a 41-yard reception touchdown and one was a 61-yard run. Even with time to prepare, Malzahn game planned around an injured Johnson and was surprised when things didn’t work.

In summation, except for 2013, Auburn’s offense has struggled finding an identity under Malzahn. In some years, such as 2015, it was never found. After essentially throwing Rhett Lashlee under the Gus Bus and hiring Chip Lindsey, it became apparent that Malzahn simply cannot let the offense out of his control. At times it was Lindsey’s offense. Other times it was the Malzahn offense. But in the really bad loss games, it was a mish-mash of the two: playing behind the line of scrimmage on first down,  stubbornly sticking to a running game on second and throwing the ball deep down the field on third with zero outlet passes in the short or intermediate passing game. Ed Orgeron’s staff said it. Scott Frost’s coaching staff said it. Auburn’s offense was predictable. The saving grace was sometimes the opposing defense couldn’t stop it. 

Auburn is now at the very top of the board in coaches’ salaries, but the money isn’t getting wins. Auburn struggles on offense in big moments, which is incongruous considering the reputation of the head coach and his staff. There is some method to that. Kodi Burns is an Auburn legend and has been on multiple Malzahn coaching staffs. In no way has his group performed at SEC caliber, much less lived up to its billing. The same can be said with Herb Hand. Malzahn and Hand coached together at Tulsa but coached an absolute sieve of a line at Penn State before coming to Auburn. That line was ranked 124th in the nation, allowing 44 sacks in the 2014 season. Auburn finished 114th in the country this season with 36.

Chip Lindsey began his college coaching career at Auburn under Malzahn. The jury is still out on him, but there hasn’t been any semblance of the type offense fans expected. Add in that no Auburn quarterback has been developed. Auburn’s best hire under Malzhan, by far, is Kevin Steele, the one coach with no Auburn or Malzahn connections. Consider all of that: Auburn’s struggles have been offensive struggles, a far cry from the fan base’s expectation of an offensive genius who only hires his own people on offense. 

This might give some perspective about what is ailing the Auburn program. Money doesn’t guarantee wins, and throwing money at coaches doesn’t make them better. Yet, Auburn extended Malzahn’s contract by seven years and 49 million dollars as he anticipated retaining the entire coaching staff. What’s wrong with this picture? 


  1. wde1988 wde1988 says:

    No adjustments at half? Who does that???

    But hey, I am a bit biased. I fell off the bus 2 years ago. And I’m still not on. Raise or no… Gus better act like he gives a damn. The performance on Saturday for me only demonstrated his contempt for those buying tickets. He won’t last long if he keeps that up. Frankly, it won’t be long before the overwhelming majority of alumni see the same thing. AU was hoodwinked again.

    I have learned my lesson. I learned never to believe a single word Malzahn says. Or did you really believe Davis had a cold or that Pettway was injured?


    • zotus zotus says:

      Well, good to hear from a familiar voice again.

      When I heard you say, a while back, that you were going to set down your glass and step away from the bar, I didn’t know you were going to be gone so long.

      But, it could be that you’ve been back, for some time, and I just wasn’t aware of it. I don’t spend as much time (for several reasons) as I used to visiting web sites where Auburn folks get together to talk about Auburn.

      But, I’ll make a deal with you. If you tell me you plan to continue to be stepping up to the bar at this particular Auburn hang-out, I’ll plan to drop in more often because I don’t want to miss any of what you have to say. Take care and WDE!

  2. uglyjoe says:

    As a former purveyor of public transportation, I pulled the cord and got off the bus following the Clemson game. As a (possibly) former sunshine pumper, I have admittedly been guilty in the past of looking too closely for the “bright side”. But for the life of me, I cannot understand why the powers at Auburn chose to reward Malzahn with the 4th (?) most lucrative contract in college football. When the rumors started about Malzahn to Arkansas, I saw a win-win situation developing…..but not to be. All we have done is increase his buyout from $5MM this year to Lord knows what next year or after……and mark my words, that buyout will get exercised. He sure isn’t going anywhere of his own volition, sitting on sack of 49 million dollar bills.

    By all accounts, Malzahn is a good guy with qualities we can all respect. Good guys don’t always win, and sometimes being the boss sucks. Sometimes the boss has to be told they are over their heads.

  3. dyingculture dyingculture says:

    I’m probably wrong, but I think Kodi Burns has done a fine job as a coach. Receivers don’t drop passes at anywhere near the same rate as in years past, so that has been fixed. Receivers know how to run routes, unlike in the past. Receivers catch the ball in stride instead of stopping and waiting for it, unlike in the past. Basic stuff, but in the past receivers weren’t doing the basic things.

    As far as Slayton, I think Slayton has also been coached up by Burns. That basket catch against Georgia wasn’t an accident – I think he was coached to do that. I think it was a direct result of the LSU game; Slayton was targeted about 8 times and he never could catch it, because LSU’s physical DBs would break the pass up. I just don’t think Slayton is a physical receiver, and that is why he always loses those 50-50 balls (seriously – seemingly always). The Georgia game was a beautiful example of how he was coached to offset his lack of physicality – notice how he intentionally slowed down with the DB on his back, and he caught the ball in such a way that only he could get his hands on it. I think that was Kodi Burns all the way.

    And remember how everyone was distraught how Dameyune Craig quit after just recruiting the best receiver class in history? Kodi Burns is getting ready to beat that recruiting class this month by a mile.

    • Zach Taylor Zach Taylor says:

      It’s a matter of perception. The SEC, overall, has such a high turnover rate at the position that we never see high polished elite talent.

      But, because I watch a ton of football for fantasy football purposes, I see guys that SEC fans don’t. Frankly, you’d be amazed at how good these guys are and it makes you ask “why don’t our guys look like that?”

  4. Zach Taylor Zach Taylor says:

    I’ll also reiterate, we are discussing catching and running routes. Im talking about gamebreakes. There’s a huge gap at auburn.

  5. Tiger4Life says:

    I appreciate the article and I’malso frustrated with the Tiger offense…particularly the passing game… When you watch the Clemson’s, Oklahoma’s and other high octane attacks– I see open receivers, back shoulder throws, etc… When Jarrett drops back, I see a ( NOBODY is OPEN and THESE ROUTES ARE TAKING WAYYY TOOOO LONG to develop, and I DON’T HAVE A SAFETY VALVE, no slants, etc )
    I’m all for balance and a great rushing attack– it’s just that the 2nd half against LSU and the bowl game against UCF show that we have no PLAN B or C when Plan A is not working…
    With the defense and kicking game we have, we should be ball control running/passing attack that keeps the ball away from the opposing offense.