arrow-circle arrow-long-stroke arrow-stroke arrow-thick arrow-thin arrow-triangle icon 2 baseballCreated with Sketch. basketball calendar category check-circle check-square check comment facebook-circle facebook-icon facebook-rounded facebook-square facebook-stroke football instagram-circle instagram-icon instagram-square long-arrow-right rss-circle rss-rounded rss-square rss-stroke rss twitter-circle twitter-icon twitter-rounded twitter-square twitter-stroke user-group user

Tigers Survive Mercer (Grading Auburn’s 24–10 win over the Mercer Bears)

By on September 18th, 2017 in Football 13 Comments »

This is why we fumble
(John Reed-USA TODAY Sports)

     War Eagle everybody. It’s time now for the Acid Reign Report on Auburn’s 24–10 homecoming win over the Mercer Bears. On one sticky afternoon in Auburn, the Tigers survived a 5-turnover night for a way too close win over the FCS Bears. Never in my wildest dreams did I figure Auburn would be clinging to a 7-point lead in the 4th quarter in this game and would need Mercer miscues and a short scoring drive to seal the win with less than 5 minutes left.

     Auburn had chances to have a big offensive day and did finish with 510 total yards while holding the Bears to 246. However, the offense had a hard time getting out of its own way on crucial downs. Possession after possession ended with miscues, whether it was an interception, a penalty, a missed chip-shot field goal, or missed blocks. And of course there were the fumbles. Tiger players lost the ball 5 times, and 4 of those were recovered by the Bears.

     Miscues aside, there was a night-and-day difference in execution from last week to this week. Of course, much of that might be attributable to playing an FCS defense rather than the defense of the defending national champion. I’m a little less concerned about Jarrett Stidham this week. Clemson’s defense made returning Heisman trophy winner Lamar Jackson look bad this week, too. Against the Bears, Stidham hit an incredible 32 of 37 passes for 364 yards. Folks, it would be hard to be that accurate running skeleton drills with no defenders on the field.

     The offensive issues this week that I would most note are outside receivers that can’t get separation from defenders and play calling in the run game. After the past couple of weeks, I have to wonder if the Auburn coaches know what a sweep or an off-tackle play is. Auburn seems to game-plan exclusively to run between the tackles, regardless of how many defenders are in the box. Kamryn Pettway shouldered the entire rushing load this past week and scored all three Auburn touchdowns. However, he was also limping noticeably. How in the world does this coaching staff give Pettway 34 carries, while injured, with the talent Auburn has on the bench at running back?

     Defensively, Auburn stifled the Mercer attack time and time again but may have been worn down a bit by the 4th quarter, thanks to the Auburn turnovers. Mercer solidly won the time of possession battle. Statistically, Auburn is among the best defenses in the nation after week 3, giving up just an average of 201 yards per game in total yardage. What concerned me during this game were the zeroes. Auburn forced no fumbles, had no interceptions, and had no sacks.

     Special teams had some issues as well, in this game. Auburn had another missed field goal attempt, this time from point-blank range. There was a shanked punt and a lost fumble on a punt return. On a positive note, I was glad to see Auburn fielding more punts, this week. Mercer punted 8 times, and Auburn returned 5. Even if the return is only a short one, that eliminates a lot of yards from rolling footballs.

Unit grades after the jump!

Defensive Line: B-. For the most part, these guys filled gaps and took running lanes away but did not get Mercer freshman quarterback Kaelan Riley on the ground in the backfield. The Auburn line contributed 3 tackles for losses and 12 total tackles.

Linebackers: B-. The Auburn linebackers continue to do a good job of filling lanes and hunting the football down. The linebackers managed 2 tackles for a loss and 20 total tackles.

Secondary: B. I counted off, perhaps unfairly, for allowing some long completions on a late scoring drive by Mercer. The Bears hit 20 of 32 passes but only for 4.5 yards per pass. By comparison, Auburn averaged 9.8 in this game. The secondary contributed 24 total tackles.

Punting: D+. Auburn only punted twice and got a pretty good 45 yarder on one of them. The other only traveled 28 yards. That’s an average of 36.5 yards. You’d like to see at least 40 yards per punt in the SEC, probably more. On the year, Ian Shannon is averaging 39.9 yards per punt.

Punt Returns: B-. I liked the 4 returns for 31 yards by Stephen Roberts. I did not like the Ryan Davis fumble. A lost fumble on a punt return is one of the most damaging things that can happen in the field position battle. That’s a letter grade, at least, to lose the ball on a punt return.

Kick Returns: A. Mercer was not going to kick it to the Auburn return men. On 3 kickoffs, one went for a touchback, and a second went out of bounds. The third was a short one, and it was nicely fielded by Spencer Nigh to prevent a possible turnover.

Place Kicking: B. A missed field goal from 26 yards brings this grade down. On the season, Daniel Carlson has hit on 5 of 8 field goals. Carlson was perfect on kickoffs, booting all 5 for touchbacks.

Offensive Line: C. It was a better effort than the week before, particularly in terms of communication and assignments. However, the line did not get as much push as I thought they should have on run plays. A lot of Auburn’s running issues were not with the line, as the line can only block 5 defenders, and Mercer routinely had 7 or 8 guys tracking the running back. It was particularly good to see the line carry on without missing a beat after right tackle Darius James went down. Austin Golson moved out to right tackle and did a pretty good job. Likewise, Casey Dunn filled in decently at center after Golson moved to tackle.

Running Backs: B-. I counted off a letter grade for the lost fumble when Auburn appeared to be headed for a touchdown. Kamryn Pettway had all of Auburn’s running back carries and finished with 34 carries for 128 yards. That’s a pedestrian average of 3.8 yards per carry. Pettway also caught 3 passes for 32 yards. We saw freshman back Devan Barrett this week, too, but he was used exclusively as a receiver with 3 catches for 17 yards. Here is another example of Auburn having too many specialized packages. If we bring Barrett in, the defense knows that a pass is coming his way, and that he’s no threat to get a handoff.

Receivers: C. A couple of lost fumbles kill what could have been a pretty good grade. The outside receivers are having issues getting open. A lot of that is design. If the outside guys run straight go-routes every single down with never a crisp cut, the defender will be able to stay with them. Auburn had an interception on a slant-pass. Nate Craig-Myers had inside position on that pass, but a defender played through him and came up with the ball after it went through Craig-Myers’ hands. Complaints aside, Auburn’s slot receivers gave Mercer fits. Ryan Davis and Will Hastings combined for 12 catches, and freshman Noah Igbinoghene had 3 more.

Quarterback: B+. I might be grading this low after Jarrett Stidham had a near Auburn-record number of completions and but one interception. However, he had a LOT of time to throw on some downs and held the ball forever. Stidham has incredible accuracy when he does let that ball go.

     As much as I have complained about some coaching decisions this season, I applaud the decision to work on the passing game this week. It had to be done, and it needs to continue and needs to take the next step next week. Otherwise, Auburn was in danger of becoming one-dimensional heading into the meat of the SEC schedule.

     A road trip to Missouri is next. Mizzou is struggling mightily this season, and on paper, this is another good chance to get a win and work on issues. However, taking an SEC team lightly is always a bad idea. Down the road from Mizzou, Auburn’s biggest obstacle before the Iron Bowl appears to be in just two weeks. Mississippi State comes to town on September 30th. The Bulldogs served notice that they are moving up in the world with a 37–7 thrashing of LSU.


  1. AUglenn says:

    I was concerned if coaches made right decission about Stidhiam and While till Saturday. I know it was Mercer but 32 passes for 365 yards and only one 50-50 interception is a big time day. Stidham had alot of rust to shake of after not playing for two years. I think he'll get better every game if he continues to be protected by the line.

  2. AUNation AUNation says:

    I was inside JH Saturday for the snooze fest with a pretty good view. My opinion is that JS throws a very pretty ball. The interception was not his fault, thr ball was on target but the DB attacked the ball and NCM did not.

    But JS lacks confidence in himself and his WRs right now. He would pump fake and decide not to throw 5 times on every drop back before he would finally release or tuck and scramble. And he is NOT going to throw to a man who is one on one with decent coverage just allowing him to make a play. Not happening. Zero 50/50 balls. Also, the OL did a much better job in pass protection.

    JS had all day… you mentioned a passing skeleton, well that's what it looked like most of the day. JSs internal clock is going to have to get quicker and he is going to have to take some chances going forward or we will see a lot of sacks this year. You can't expect any OLs to hold elite DEs that long.

    But as good as the OL looked on pass protect they looked equally as bad on the run. Yes, Mercer knew the run was coming and we were stubbornly running Pettway into a loaded box, but you still expect to see some overmatched outclassed wins against a Mercer DL.

    What I saw was our lineman getting stoned and stood up, and no one getting to the second level. LBs were still running free and Pettway found almost no holes except on the wildcat, when he decided to bounce outside on his own. Call it arrogant, but AU should be able to line up and run a HB dive over and over straight down the field against Mercer and average 4 yards per carry.

    I'm glad the offense got some work and hope the fumblitis is an anomoly, but thank God it was Mercer this week or it could have been us losing to Mississippi State by 30.

    • AubTigerman AubTigerman says:

      Good thoughts AUNation. I was at the game too and “snooze fest” pretty much describes how it felt. I was pleased with Stidham but would like to see him have a quicker release. He will need that when he faces some SEC defenses. Also the WR’s made some good catches as with Craig-Myers one handed behind him catch. But I agree they need to fight for the ball more.

  3. dyingculture dyingculture says:

    I sort of suspect the reason why the coaching staff kept handing the ball off to only Pettway is because they didn’t like the way the OL was playing, and they wanted the starters in there for the reps. I remember a game against San Jose State – I think it was 2014 – when Malzahn didn’t like the way the OL was blocking the run, so he ran the almost same exact running play 18 times in a row.

  4. jlobailey says:

    I agree with most of what I read. Maybe the defense was graded too harshly. They played a ridiculous amount of snaps. Its hard to maintain play like they did for such long stretches.

    Also, I'm wondering why people aren't talking more about Stidham's indecisive play. He just seems so hesitant to get rid of it. I saw nobody talking about it after the Clemson game (although they were quick to trash the Oline) and few after Mercer. Oline had fantastic pass pro on Saturday, and Stidham still seemed nervous. Its his job to get the ball out in 5 seconds (at the most 7) regardless of receiver play.

  5. audude audude says:

    Acid, even with all the talk of offensive execution whatever happened to the methodology of running multiple plays using the same personel? Gus did that to perfection 7 years ago. If I remember correctly, he would even run a play in the 1st half to get the defense to play it one way and set up the same look in the 2nd half and run a different play catching the defense flat. He did that on multiple plays throughout the game.


  6. Tigers5711 says:

    I’ve been an Auburn fan for 60 years and have come to a shocking conclusion It seems that coaches at AU are impressive at first but tend to underperform as time goes on. Has anyone else notices this?

    Shug won an NC in his 7th year and went undefeated again in 1958 with one tie but never won the SEC again in the next 18 years although 1963 and 1972 were good years, He inherited a team in 1951 that was winless the year before, Probation didn’t help either.

    Dye came within an inch of winning an NC in his 3rd year but the polls jumped Miami over us, He did win the SEC 3 more times but never came close to an NC again in 12 years, He got Bama to come to Auburn to play our home games beginning in 1989 but recruiting violations did him in.

    Bowden went undefeated his first year and won his first 20 games and later won the SEC West. But lack of recruiting did him in within 51/2 years

    Tuberville won the SEC West in his second year and had a perfect season in his 5th year which gave us number 1 after USC vacated their NC later but never threatened to win an NC again in his ten years. He did beat Bama 6 years in a row and beat Bama 7 out of 10 years,

    Chizik won the NC in his second year but never had a decent season for the next 3 years.

    Malzahn got within 13 seconds of winning an NC in his first year but has had mediocre seasons since

  7. Tiger4Life says:

    Re: Stidham holding the ball too long– IMHO, he would be happy to get rid of it just as soon as the target is OPEN… What kind of routes are our receivers running?

  8. Tiger4Life says:

    Ok…I had to add my own addendum to my previous comment…
    32 of 37 for 364 yards is awesome!… but I would like us to hit our WR’s in stride a bit more for YAC… Hopefully, we’ll keep growing offensively all year…

  9. Third Generation Tiger Third Generation Tiger says:

    Thanks for the recap Acid. Keen insight as usual. Excellent point about player substitutions and the limited/specific plays each back tips off to the defense. Did you happen to notice if the gameplan allowed for more quick developing patterns? Was anything done with the play calling that would negate or slow down a very aggressive pass rush?

    • Acid Reign Acid Reign says:

      ……We had a few slant, snag and quickouts for the slot receivers. Ryan Davis got 9 balls, and Will Hastings caught 3, out of these sorts of routes. However, the lack of outside runs did not do much to slow down the rush. What helped this week is that Mercer didn’t have a D-line like Clemson did.

      • Third Generation Tiger Third Generation Tiger says:

        I hope they scheme up something soon. After watching parts of all three games it looks like the offense is working on stuff that should have been ironed out in the spring.
        Thanks for the info.